FrostyTech Mk.III Synthetic Thermal Heatsink Test Results - 200W Intel Core i7, Extreme Edition class heatsinks tested at a 200W heat load. Results based on readings from a 38x38mm copper interface die with 200W heat load on the Intel version of the Mk.III Test Platform. Temperature results listed for each heatsink were calculated by determining the rise over ambient temperatures at time of test. Information on Frostytech's test methodology is available here. Socket LGA2011-3 / 2011 /1366 compatible CPU heatsinks
manufacturer:	model no.:	*fan speed:	200w thermal test (°c)	noise level (dba)
Coolermaster	Nepton 280L	high	10.6	58.8
Coolermaster	Nepton 140XL	high	11.8	59.6
Arctic	Liquid Freezer 240	high	12.2	46.0
Coolermaster	MasterLiquid 240	high	12.3	54.8
Coolermaster	Seidon 240M	high	13.4	55.6
Silverstone	Tundra TD02	high	13.6	53.0
DeepCool	Maelstrom 240	high	13.8	58.6
Coolermaster	Glacer 240L	high	14.1	52.5
NZXT	Kraken X60	high	14.5	60.7
Coolermaster	Nepton 240M	high	15.1	50.6
Noctua	NH-D15	high	15.8	49.8
Noctua	NH-U14S		17.0	47.3
Arctic	Liquid Freezer 120	high	17.3	46.0
Coolermaster	Seidon 120V	high	17.5	54.3
Alphacool	Eisbaer 240	high	17.7	52.1
NZXT	Kraken X40	high	18.2	59.4
Reeven	Okeanos RC-1402	high	18.3	54.2
Reeven	Ouranos RC-1401	high	18.4	52.5
Silverstone	Tundra TD03	high	18.7	58.1
Silverstone	Argon AR01	high	18.8	53.0
X2 Products	Eclipse IV	high	19.1	57.4
Coolermaster	Eisberg 240L	high	19.1	50.5
BeQuiet	Dark Rock TF		19.2	44.5
Reeven	Justice RC-1204	high	19.2	48.5
BeQuiet	Dark Rock Pro 3	high	19.5	43.7
Scythe	Fuma	high	19.6	49.1
Raijintek	Themis	high	19.7	52.8
Coolermaster	V8 GTS	high	20.0	59.7
BeQuiet	Dark Rock 3	high	20.9	41.8
Corsair	Hydro H80i	high	21.1	64.0
Noctua	NH-U12S		21.1	46.2
Raijintek	Ereboss	high	21.4	49.7
Zalman	Reserator 3 Max	high	21.6	58.9
Scythe	Mugen 4	high	21.7	41.9
Cryorig	H5 Ultimate	high	21.9	47.1
Zalman	LQ315	high	21.9	50.8
Silverstone	NT06-P	high	22.1	51.6
Raijintek	Pallas	high	22.2	43.2
Gelid	Tranquillo 4 (LGA1366)	high	22.4	46.9
Scythe	Ashura SCASR-1000	high	22.5	49.4
DeepCool	Gamer Storm Lucifer	high	23.0	52.5
Raijintek	Aidos	high	23.0	55.6
Reeven	Hans RC-1205	high	23.1	49.4
Gamerstorm	Lucifer K2	high	23.2	55.2
Silentium	Fera2 HE1224	high	23.4	37.6
Zalman	LQ310	high	23.8	52.7
Coolermaster	Hyper D92	high	24.1	53.4
Phanteks	PH-TC14S	high	24.2	47.4
Scythe	Ashura Shadow (SCASR-1000SE)	high	24.2	51.4
Scythe	Mugen 5 Rev.B	high	24.4	43.4
Raijintek	Tisis	high	24.6	47.8
BeQuiet	Shadow Rock Slim	high	24.7	40.4
BeQuiet	Shadow Rock 2	high	24.9	43.3
Scythe	Ninja 4	high	25.5	43.2
Zalman	LQ320	high	25.5	50.2
ID-Cooling	SE-214X	high	26.5	46.3
Gelid	Antarctica (LGA1366)	high	26.6	49.8
Noctua	NH-D9DXi4 3U (front +2nd Fan)		27.7	47.4
BeQuiet	Shadow Rock LP		27.9	42.6
BeQuiet	PureRock		27.9	42.9
npowertek	NPH-1366-115HC (LGA1366)	high	28.7	44.8
Dynatron	G556 (LGA1366/2U)		29.1	68.4
Noctua	NH-U9S		30.2	44.3
Dynatron	G555 (LGA1366/2U)		30.4	67.8
Dynatron	G666 (LGA1366/2U)		31.8	68.7
Noctua	NH-D9L		32.0	43.2
Scythe	Mugen Max SCMGD-1000	high	34.2	48.7
Noctua	NH-D9DXi4 3U		34.9	44.6
Silverstone	NT01-Pro	high	35.8	40.4
nPowerTek	NPH1366-140HC (LGA1366)	high	36.3	48.1
Phanteks	PH-TC12LS	high	36.4	43.4
Zalman	FX-100 (w/h ZM-F2 fan)		36.9	28.5
Scythe	Mugen 5 Rev.B	low	38.8	35.6
Noctua	NH-L9x65	high	44.8	46.1
Dynatron	G199 (LGA1366/1U)		47.6	62.6
Zalman	FX-100 (hor, ver)		63.0	0.0
			200w thermal test (°c)	noise level (dba)
*heatsinks are ranked according to the 200w thermal test results column (rise over ambient temp.). low temperatures with low noise levels are considered best. for reference heatsinks with variable-speed fans, only the high speed (12v) fan test result is included in the comparison sheet; more detailed results reside in each specific heatsink review.

frostytech's socket LGA2011 Intel synthetic thermal test platform stresses socket LGA2011/1366 compatible heatsinks with a 200W heat load. Keep in mind that the AMD Integrated Heat Spreader and Intel LGA2011 Integrated Heat Spreader both measure ~38x38mm, so these test results can be extrapolated to AMD processor scenario's as well.

With a 200W heat load applied by the Intel LGA2011/1366 version of FrostyTech's synthetic thermal test platform, the Scythe Mugen 5 Rev B heatsink yields a pretty good temperature result of 24.4°C over ambient at stock fan speed (1200RPM / 43.4dBA).

Slowing the 120mm fan to 600RPM lowers noise levels to a quiet 35.6 dBA, however the reduced air pressure and decreased air flow cause test temperatures to increase to 38.8°C over ambient.

Bottom Line?

The heatsink reference charts include a lot of all-in-one watercoolers and heatsinks which are taller than 154mm - so let's filter the results down a little and compare the Scythe Mugen 5 Rev B heatsink only to air coolers which are less than 155mm tall on the 200W heatsink reference chart. This subset places the Scythe Mugen 5 Rev B at about 9th place, behind the BeQuiet Dark Rock TF, Scythe Fuma, Raijintek Pallas, Coolermaster Hyper D92 among others. Of these, only two offer comparable low noise output to the Mugen 5 Rev B.

( Heat distribution shown via kapton tape adhered to the edge of the fins 10mm from top and bottom. Temperature increases by roughly 3°C from left to right on the Mugen 5 Rev B as the moving air mass picks up heat. )

Considering the results from all three synthetic thermal test platforms on the whole, the Scythe Mugen 5 Rev B heatsink offers up average to very good thermal performance with a low noise signature and is a mid-tower air cooler well worth considering for your next CPU!

Related Articles:

The Top 5 best heatsinks for low noise and low temperature are ranked here. For more reviews on the latest heatsinks and cooling solutions, rely on FrostyTech's inventory of 400+ heatsink reviews. Here are a few other articles that you might enjoy as well.

- Phanteks PH-TC14S Slim Tower Heatsink Review
- Noctua NH-U9S Compact Lower Noise Heatsink Review
- BeQuiet Pure Rock Heatsink Review
- Cooler Master Nepton 240M Liquid Cooling System Review
- Coolermaster Hyper D92 Heatsink Review
- BeQuiet Shadow Rock 2 Heatsink Review
- Scythe Ashura SCASR-1000 Heatsink Review