FrostyTech.com Heatsink Reviews and Analysis
> GO < Search
TOP 5 BEST Heat Sinks     SEARCH     All Heat Sinks     News     Reviews    
Quick Links
° Reviews and ArticlesFrostytech News RSS Feed
° Breaking News
° Mfg's Index
° Top 5 Heatsinks
° Top 5 Low Profile   Heatsinks

Top 5 Heatsink Charts


What's New in Heatsinks?
°  Gelid Solutions Tranquillo

°  Prolimatech Super Mega

°  Noctua NH-U12P SE2 Silent CPU Cooler

°  Zalman ZM-NC3000U Notebook Cooler Review

°  Anatomy of Computer Fans

°  Ready for Summer Heat: Liquid-Cooling Components


- or - Best 5 Heatsinks?
Zalman ZM-2HC1 Heatpipe HDD Cooler Review
Zalman ZM-2HC1 Heatpipe HDD Cooler Review
Overall Rating:   0%
Abstract: A better solution recently came to light in the form of Zalman's ZM-2HC1 heatpipe hard drive cooling rack, primarily because it addresses the noise and vibration factor.

 Company link     Category     Published     Author    
Zalman   $$ Price It! ££ Cooling / Heatsinks   May 24, 2004   M. Page  
Home > Reviews > Page Title: Testing the ZM-2CH1

If you regularly listen to your hard drive grinding away, chances are the case it is screwed into is amplifying the noises to an extent. By isolating a hard drive from the metal frame of a case, you can potentially cut back on these sorts of sounds.

Though, this is highly dependent on the drive and case being used, and will be different for each particular instance.

Testing the ZM-2HC1: As a general rule, we prefer to test cooling devices on a synthetic test bed, but sometimes that just isn't possible. To test out the Zalman ZM-2HC1 we've enlisted the help of a Seagate 120GB hard drive and an Omega HH501DK thermometer.

To measure temperatures from the hard drive a Type-K thermocouple was placed directly over the center of the platters, and held in place with some tape. With the thermocouple is insulated from passing air currents with a small piece of foam, we proceeded to test the hard drive with and without the Zalman ZM-2CH1 installed.

The results are pretty simple; without anything attached to the Seagate drive we recorded temperatures on the order of 39.3 degrees Celsius, and with the Zalman ZM-2CH1 installed the drives temperature dropped to about 37.0 degrees Celsius. The drive was mounted to the base of a case, and was tested for passive cooling alone.

I was considering adding in some results the Zalman ZM-2CH1 with a little added airflow care of a case mounted fan, but there are so many variables that the results wouldn't be worth much use. We tested a couple different configurations, and in each case the temperature of the drive naturally dropped, but how much you can expect temperatures to fall all depends on fan positioning, airflow, case pressure, and ambient temperatures. Suffice to say, with a fan blowing on the Zalman ZM-2CH1, the unit is able to cool a hard drive better than if the hard drive is left alone.

Zalman ZM-2CH1 HDD Cooler From All Angles
The Fan:
There are (10) 5mm diameter heatpipes on the Zalman ZM-2CH1, and each one is about 160mm long. The device works by using the exposed copper heatsinks as the cooling surface.

Heatsink Top:
Thanks to some pre-drilled holes, the Zalman ZM-2CH1 installs in just a few seconds. Notice how the copper heatpipes rise up over the top where the drive sits. Zalman include all the necessary hardware to mount the unit to a case, or 5.25" bay.

Side A:
The blue anodized aluminum side bars attach directly to the side of the hard drive where they absorb the heat which is then transferred to the copper heatpipes.

Side B:
The aluminum portion of the Zalman ZM-2CH1 is simply made up of two extruded aluminum sections mounted together. The heatpipes mounte into the space between them, and screws hold everything in place. To mount the Zalman ZM-2CH1 and hard drive to the base of a case, the little rubber vibration absorbing posts actually screw into the hard drive. Since the copper heatpipes are uncoated, they will eventually tarnish from the shinny copper colour shown here.

Ultimately, I think the Zalman ZM-2CH1 hard drive cooler is a bit of luxury; it does work to lower the overall temperature of a hard drive, but the hard drive really doesn't need to be cooled to that degree. At least not in a typical desktop computer.

If we look at a totally silent case where there are no cooling fans in the case, in the power supply, or elsewhere, I think the Zalman ZM-2CH1 would certainly have a more important role to play in maintaining acceptable hard drive temperatures. But again, it is not a really critical item to have.

That being said, where Zalman have really done the low noise cooling enthusiast a helping hand is by bundling in this heatpipe based hard drive cooling with vibration absorbing rubber mounting points. While the cooling factor is debatable for a standard case, the affect of neutralizing parasitic case vibrations caused by a noisy hard drive in a silent PC is quiet important.

By catering to that application, Zalman have given the Zalman ZM-2CH1 a few tangible qualities which I'm sure a silent PC enthusiast will appreciate. Bottom line though, unless you are really working to build a fully silent case, the Zalman ZM-2CH1 isn't going to be fully utilized.

 Previous Page ° The Top 5 Heatsinks...

Article Contents:
 Page 1:  Zalman ZM-2HC1 Heatpipe HDD Cooler Review
 Page 2:  — Testing the ZM-2CH1

Resources
° Got Feedback?
° Mk.II Test Platform
° Heatsink Reviews
° Manufacturer Index
° Industry Dir.
° Cooling Projects
EverCool Thermal
Recently Tested

Thermaltake Contac 29 Heatsink Review

Zaward Vapor 120 Heatsink Review

Dynatron Genius G950 Heatsink Review

Gelid Tranquillo Heatsink Review

Zalman CNPS10X Performa Heatsink Review

Scythe Grand Kama Cross SCKC-2000 Heatsink Review
...More Articles >>

Tech Polls
Thermal Compound Testing
How much would you pay to read a comprehensive test report of various CPU Thermal Compound pastes?
Nothing
$2 - $4
$5 - $10
Number of votes: 1739

Websites you may also like:
Silent PC Review
Cooling-Masters
Matbe.com

Google Search Frostytech
Time stamped: 12:19PM, 07.30.2010



Member of The Rydium Network

Find a Heatsink / RSS Feeds
Latest Heatsink Reviews
Top 5 Heatsinks Tested
FrostyTech News RSS Feed
FrostyTech Reviews RSS Feed


FrostyTech.com Info
Feedback
Contact Us / Heatsink Submissions
Submit News
Legal

 
 
© Copyright 1999-2010 www.frostytech.com. All Rights Reserved. Privacy policy and Terms of Use
Images are © FrostyTech.com and may not be reproduced without express written permission.