FrostyTech.com Heatsink Reviews and Analysis
      
TOP 5 Heat Sinks     TOP 5 Low Profile Heat Sinks     TOP 5 Liquid Coolers    
 Reviews + Articless     News     HSF Mfg's Index     Advanced Search    

Cooling Fundamentals: Ball Vs. Sleeve Bearings
Cooling Fundamentals: Ball Vs. Sleeve Bearings
  0%   
Abstract: What's the fuss over ball and sleeve bearings in todays cooling fans? Heck, what's even the difference? Read on and know more then anyone around you about these little, but important things.

 Company link  Category  Published  Author 
FrostyTech.com   Cooling / Heatsinks   Apr 26, 2000   Max Page  
Home > Reviews > Page Title: In the field issues

In some applications sleeve bearings are superior to ball bearings, but within the confines of the computer, the current peripherals are not taking into consideration the extra measures necessary to keep sleeve bearings in top performance. When ball bearing fans fail, they slow down or rattle (after years of abuse mind you) but when sleeve bearings fail (under ideal conditions of a computer system) the failure is more absolute, noise or total seizure impart immediate loss of performance, ball bearings seem to fail more gracefully over time, with plenty of warning signals.

Those two traits are what distinguish ball bearings as superior to sleeve bearings in many fan systems (and in MY opinion). Many but not all. Sleeve bearings require more intensive designs, and long-term planning. Ball bearings tend to be more forgiving. Hence when presented with two fan systems, why is the ball bearing based fan considered the better choice?

Because most 60mm x 10mm fans are made by OEM's in great quantities for very small costs per unit. To be competitive with other manufactures the features built into the fan are kept to a minimum. Designing to a minimum is ideal for ball bearings as they do not require much long term thought. The difference then comes when sleeve bearings are used in the same competitive design framework. The result can be a fan designed for ball bearings, but using sleeve bearings. 

Take for instance this generic OEM fan which at first glance appears to utilize a sleeve bearings. In actuality it uses a 3mm high ball bearing and a 3mm high sleeve bearing - blurring the lines between what is and isn't ball bearing.
This duality emphasizes the point that some small computer fans are using sleeve bearings in situations designed for ball bearings. This fan illustrates the point perfectly - the thrust washer has been enlarged to enable smaller sized ball bearings to be used.

Why do we believe that the fans are being designed for ball bearings and used with sleeve bearings? Well if you look at high quality fans like Nidec or Rodale, or essentially any brand name, you will notice some differences common to their sleeve bearing designs. The sleeve bearings are isolated and shielded from debris and contaminants by complex designs which also help to preserve the lubricant over time.

In this diagram of a Nidec sleeve bearing assembly take note of the "labyrinth" designed into the fan to prevent the sleeve bearings from drying out and failing.

With less expensive fans coming packaged with the average heatsink, most sleeve bearings are easily visible beneath the fans sticker. Some on the other hand, are camouflaged by bronze thrust washers like the fan below. Telling one from the other can become quite complicated with systems of this nature. While the bronze thrust washer in this instance serves no real bearing duty, the interchangeability of the two types of bearings is an interesting point.

If some precautions are taken even the life span of these 'lower' quality fans can be lengthened. With the majority of the the bearings being accessible from underneath a sticker label, a small dab of lubricant on the top of the apparent sleeve bearing will go a long way to keeping them in excellent condition. The oil will be drawn in by capillary actions and distributed towards the shaft. Sleeve bearings, when properly lubricated can last for a very long time and provide performance on par with ball bearings. A reservoir of grease next to the bearing can also be helpful overtime. If sleeve bearings are improperly lubricated (or run at consistenly high temperatures) they can die relatively quickly (6 - 12 mos).



 Previous Page °
° Next Page 

Table of Contents:

 1:  Cooling Fundamentals: Ball Vs. Sleeve Bearings
 2:  Sleeve Bearings
 3: — In the field issues
 4:  Conclusions

List all FrostyTech.com heat sinks that Frostytech tested?

Follow Frostytech on FacebookFrostytech News RSS FeedFollow frostytech on Twitter
Resources
° Got Feedback?
° Mk.II Test Platform
° Where To Buy?
° Manufacturer Index
° Industry Dir.
° Cooling Projects

Scythe Ninja 4 SCNH-4000 Heatsink Review

DeepCool Maelstrom 240 Liquid Cooling System Review

DeepCool Gamer Storm Lucifer K2 Heatsink Review

Gelid Antarctica Heatsink Review

Noctua NH-D9L 3U Low Noise Heatsink Review

BeQuiet Shadow Rock LP Heatsink Review
...More Articles >>




Websites you may also like:
PCSTATS

Google Search Frostytech

Time stamped: 8:38AM, 11.21.2017
In Case You Missed it...
°  Scythe Mugen 5 Rev B SCMG-5100 Heatsink Review

°  Samsung to continue adopting heat pipes for smartphones in 2018

°  be quiet! Dark Base 700 Case Review

°  Cooler Master MasterBox Pro 5 Revealed

°  ARCTIC Freezer 33 eSports Edition CPU Cooler Review

°  Heatpipes to watercooler CPU Heatsink - DIY




FrostyTech.com
Since June 1999


Find a Heatsink / RSS Feeds
Latest Heatsink Reviews
Top 5 Heatsinks Tested
News RSS Feed
Reviews RSS Feed


Social Media
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest


FrostyTech.com Info
Feedback
Contact Us / Heatsink Submissions
Submit News
Legal
Suite 66
© Copyright 1999-2017 www.frostytech.com All Rights Reserved. Privacy policy and Terms of Use
Images © FrostyTech.com and may not be reproduced without express written permission.
Current students and faculty of accredited Universities may use Frostytech images in research papers and thesis, provided each image is attributed.